AJ Lee is back — and the hyperbole machine is already in overdrive. Just as John Cena’s “heel turn” was once dubbed the best in history, AJ’s return is now being hailed as the greatest comeback ever. Some fans even say it’s the third best return in her own house. Whatever the ranking, there’s no denying the shockwaves it’s sending through the wrestling world.

We break down what AJ’s return means for WWE, how it stacks up against CM Punk’s legendary comeback, and what it says about the power of nostalgia in wrestling. We also look at AEW’s ongoing perception issues — was the residency too long? — and why Eddie Kingston’s New York grit might be exactly what the company needs.

From MJF’s evolution to the women’s division taking two steps forward and one step back, to whether we’re in a preseason lull, to tag team dream matches and shocking title wins on TV — this episode dives deep into why wrestling thrives on hype, surprises, and the larger-than-life moments that keep fans talking long after the bell rings.

⏱️ Chapters:

00:00 - AJ Lee's Historic Return

09:29 - The Best Returns in Wrestling History ‍️

15:02 - Fear of Overstaying Welcome

22:58 - Logistical Challenges of Venues ️

29:03 - Nostalgia and the Future of WWE ️

34:55 - Disappointment with Big Bill's Handling

42:56 - The Misdirection Theory on Eddie Kingston

45:08 - Eddie Kingston's Role in Mox Redemption Story

47:16 - Concerns Over Story Development

1:01:57 - Lulls in Wrestling Storylines

1:05:08 - Women's Division Issues ‍

1:17:00 - Match Stipulations for MJF vs. Brisco

1:31:18 - Wrapping Up the Conversation

🎧 Listen & Subscribe:

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@GWPodcastUK?sub_confirmation=1

Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/5PjvtX5m2QG657MCBcS9is

Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/the-groupchat-wrestling-podcast/id1758973539

🐦 Connect With Us:

Twitter: https://twitter.com/GWPodcastUK

Discord: https://discord.com/invite/YrfmfBepJM

BlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/gwpodcastuk.bsky.social

👍 Like, comment, and subscribe for weekly wrestling chaos, AEW breakdowns, Britwres dives, and moments that should not exist.

#WrestlingPodcast #AEW #WWE #ajlee #eddiekingston #hook #cmpunk #aewdynamite #theelite

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.